Comment: Although ATC was on a piece of cardboard... as per swap requirements: Make something of quality that you'd like to receive and keep. 2.5" x 3.5", make it sturdy, any materials you want)! Art on the front, title, artist name and date on the back. Not only was the ATC just a stamp with a name written in marker (your "tattoo"), there was absolutely no information on the back ( I can certainly provide a photo if you believe what you sent is as you have described). I'm sorry you feel this is adequate but I am generous and will re-rate if you re-send and meet swap requirements. Happy swappnig!